Tuesday, March 2, 2010

What theme in common have you observed in "Coming Home Again," and "Shooting Dad"?

“Coming Home Again” and “Shooting Dad” has a common theme of love and family. In Coming Home again the son Chang-Rae-Lee is sent off to boarding school. His mother didn’t want him to become like her so she sent him off to change his character. After ten years he returns home because his mother has been diagnosed with stomach cancer. His mother now regrets that she sent him there because now their time has been cut short. They turn to cooking to find a way to reconnect and for Chang-Rae-Lee to remember her by.

The same kind of thing happens in “Shooting Dad”. Sarah Vowell is a twin and a daughter of a gunsmith. Her father loves guns. At the age of six her father has her and her twin shoot their first gun. Sarah did not like the gun. It terrified her. As for her sister she loved it. Sarah thought she had nothing in common with her dad. They grew apart. Down the road she decided to try to enjoy her time with her dad. She goes with him to shoot off his cannon for the first time and at that moment she realizes that her and her dad are a lot a like. “We are both smart-alecky loners with goofy projects and weird equipment.” At that point they found a way to connect.

7 comments:

  1. I agree Michelle, love and family are strong themes in these two essays. Maybe elaborating in your own words about love and family would be a great start for your essay next week.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also agree with you and like how you explain how both essays are similar. Have you came up with your thesis statement though? What do you think about the two essays? I think it is a good start but more critical thinking would help make your essay stronger.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You have done a good job at summarizing and quoting the stories. I would suggest that you now elaborate on common theme and what that might mean to you. What did you take away from the readings?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think it might help if you eased into the essay a little softer. your first paragraph is almost like a summary of the two stories. Maybe open up describing the love families share and the bonds the characters share. then go into your supportive paragraphs.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You have done a great job in describing the differences between the two essays. It's amazing how we all grow up and have our different interests.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Family was a strong theme in both of those stories. They start off not really getting along due to different interest but then bond with each other towards the end. They were able to find their common inner self.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hey,
    you did a good job in relating both of the stories. I also liked how you included a quote from the story i think that is going to help u with find similarities in both of the stories and how they relate to each other.

    ReplyDelete