What's the importance of forgiveness in "Smoke Signals"? How does Victor learn to forgive his father?
In the movie “Smoke Signals” it tells a story about a boy named Victor, who grew up on an Indian Reservation. He grew up with a mother and father who had marriage problems because of his father’s alcohol abuse. That alcohol abuse led to physical and mental abuse to Victor. Victor’s father leaves him at a very young age, and the hatred to him grows stronger. There is a boy named Tomas that was saved in a fire by Victor’s father. Tomas is proud to have been saved by him. Tomas talks about Victor’s father a lot and Victor hates it, because of all his hate to his father. Later in the story Victor’s father passes away. There was never a time of forgiveness when he was alive. Victor goes to collect his father belonging. Tomas goes along, only because Victor didn’t have enough money to get there. On the trip there they finally become friends. Victor finally realizes that he can forgive his father, after Tomas and him become friends.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I'm wondering what it is Victor realizes? Does Thomas, remembering Arnold because of saving him when young make Victor uncomfortable? Is Victor jealous of the love Thomas feels for victors father, the love that Victor should feel? You bring up a lot of interesting questions. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteI too think that victor is jelouse of the relationship thomas had with his father. He gets real uncomfortable when thomas talks about victor.
ReplyDeleteHi Michelle, great start! I clearly found your essay and thesis. I liked how you explained the strain in Victor and his father relationship and the problems they faced in the past. I think to make this essay stronger it would be nice to mention how and why Victor decides to forgive his father and what this means.
ReplyDeleteYou have a lot of good points. I would never think about that Victor would be jealous of Thomas. I think you should go deeper into why you believe he is jealous, like the reasons. You have a really good start and great observation.
ReplyDelete