Thursday, April 29, 2010

Why does Kiyoshi believe Obaban is a substitute for his mom?

Why does Kiyoshi believe Obaban is a substitute for his mom?
Kiyoshi’s mother is very ill. She is also very weak. In January of 1934 his mother had got all of her teeth pulled out because they were rotten. She then fainted for the second time and was back in the three bed room hospital. She was not able to eat very well and was dying. Kiyoshi’s family was very superstitions. “Mother did seem to have more superstitions than most people. She insisted that rice should always be scooped at least twice from the big bowl to the individual bowls even if the second scoop was a token one without any rice on the ladle. Double scooping protected the family from seeing a second mother, meaning your first mother would not die or run away.”
Kiyoshi goes to tell Obaban who is his granny. His mother doesn’t want to bother her. She thinks it will be to much trouble to get her over to where she is at. But Kiyoshi insists that she needs to know that she is ill and needs to come see her. Kiyoshi gets a taxi and brings her to his mother. Later in the story Kiyoshi was in class and his father was at the door. His heart started pounding and then he found out it was his grandmother. He prayed and hoped that she was dead because he wanted her to be his mothers substitute.

5 comments:

  1. Hi Michelle,

    Each time I read this chapter, I get caught up in the superstitions and physical ailments of Kiyoshi’s mother. I overlook Kiyoshi’s fear as he’s watching his mother struggle and nearly die. I love the moment that you end your post with. There’s a painful honesty in his fear that his mother is dead and joy in finding out that it’s Obaban. Thanks for this point to think about!

    Lauren :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is a good response. It is interesting how Kiyoshi was laughing at his mom's superstitious belives and at the end he believed it after Obaban died.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Michelle,
    You were on point. Kiyoshi's mother did seem more superstitious than most people. I found it sad that if he had to choose he would choose grandma to die rather than his mother. he felt Obaban had lived a full life and was good to go. I also agree with Jackie's response regarding how little Kiyoshi believed in his mothers superstitions but when the time came he could belive as long as his mother lived.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kiyoshi's mother is very superstitiuos. I think a little too much. I don't think its a good thing because it can affect an individual because you always have this fear that if you do something incorrectly you would be punish. My parents are somewhat superstitious but not as much as her.

    ReplyDelete
  5. nice thought.
    its wierd how superstitions his mother in and koyoshi never believes her untill the "subsitute" happens

    ReplyDelete